Psychiatrists warn of 70% stress and 50% depression due to confinement

Monday 6th April 2020
Translated into English by Gareth Thomas from original story by Victoria Bueno in Información de Alicante.

(Translator’s note: at the beginning of the translated article it should be emphasised more that the study initially analyses data from the observation of existing clients of the mental health service. It then goes on to make broader points about the effect on the general population. )

Specialists from the Hospital de Sant Joan and Department of Clinical Medicine of the UMH* measure the effects of enforced isolation to plan solutions

The Psychiatry service of the Sant Joan University Hospital, with the support of the Department of Clinical Medicine of the *Miguel Hernández University of Elche, has launched a project to detect the risk of disorders generated by the confinement forced by the pandemic and to be able to plan possible solutions.

From the outset, they warn that the trend points to indices that could well echo those measured last month in China, with rates of stress of the population of 70% and depression of 50% registered, as well as 44% of anxiety and 34% insomnia.

Dr. Lorena García refers in turn to the well-known consequences of other serious epidemics such as the H5N1 in Hong Kong in 1997, the Ebola outbreak in Sierra Leone in 2014 or the SARS outbreak in 2003. “All of them were accompanied by an increase in psychiatric pathology, especially anxiety, depression and post-traumatic stress,” says the expert psychiatrist.

In anticipation of these triggers, specialists from the Sant Joan hospital together with experts from the Miguel Hernández University (UMH) have decided to measure what happens in psychiatric emergencies, and have designed a “simple survey” open to the entire population.

They aim to detect and measure both acute stress and anxiety and depression symptoms, the disorders that are more likely as a consequence of confinement in the current circumstances.

(Translator’s note: I have put a hot link to the actual survey. You can access it here – naturally it is in Spanish! – and it is well worth even doing the survey yourself as a self-health check. Who can say at this moment, “I haven’t got time for that!”)

Approach

“Our goal is to measure these acute stress and anxiety and depression symptoms, so that we can subsequently design an appropriate approach plan,” says the doctor.

On the other hand, and as the president of the association of family doctors, María Ángeles Medina, recently warned, anxiety and anguish begin to take their toll even in people without previous disorders and, of course, among health workers: those who now bear the greatest weight of responsibility for keeping those affected alive.

“We are going to evaluate what is happening and once we have the still-photo of the situation we will propose the implementation of a plan to tackle the new pathologies that accompany the crisis, because the demands are going to change,” Dr. García explains.

The psychiatrists predict that there will be an avalanche of people who have never been treated before but who are going to be powerless to handle the situation, hence the interest in measuring the situation and having some prevention in place to address it in time.

One in four people at risk for mental disorder

The initial interest of the project, which was born with a focus on the risks of confinement for people with mental illnesses, has expanded significantly towards health professionals, now among the population most vulnerable to suffering mental disorders due to the pressure they suffer on a daily basis, along with the rest of the general population.

The purpose is to keep the measurements for six months “because it’s the time it takes to become post-traumatic,” experts say, while warning that about one in four people will have a mental illness throughout their lives.


5 thoughts on “Psychiatrists warn of 70% stress and 50% depression due to confinement

  1. 1. Thank you Rowland and Betty! I just had an automated email message saying you commented, and I’ve turned the moderation OFF now! (It shouldn’t have been on and readers are free to comment.)

    2. Just a reminder to the gradually growing community of readers: this is an English language social support project for villagers of Sella, Orxeta and Finestrat (Costa Blanca, Alicante.) Anybody is welcome to comment here but comments should please be relevant to the theme of the post.

    3. I notice from the overnight site statistics that majority of readers of the present article, “Psychiatrists warn of 70% stress and 50% depression due to confinement” were in the USA. This is probably due to the small regular American readers (some of whom have their own “donkey blogs”) sharing this site more widely with others in the USA. The COVID-19 theme is now relevant to a wider audience in the USA.

    Now, as I promised myself it is my day off, so no more from me today. How will I spend my day off? I now have a choice: I could spend the day paying on my knees asking for the intercessions of Our Lady and all the angels and saints, to intervene and miraculously cure Boris Johnson from the plague; or I could just go and spend the day in the garden.

    Now: where did I put that box of runner bean seeds… ?

    Like

  2. I have completed the Sant Joan University Hospital and Miguel Hernández University of Elche survey and submitted it. It is very enlightening and I recommend anyone that is able to do so – even if you do not wish to submit it.

    Like

  3. Hi Frank,
    I know already from some of the little insights that I’ve been getting into these issues, we shall be dealing with the effects of this long after the virus itself has ceased to be a threat. There will be some form of tested and approved innoculation within a time frame of 12 months – 18 months. There is no medical fix for the stresses that have produced long term interpersonal relationship damage, trauma for those who have a natural disposition towards unnecessary or undue worry (rather than simply adopt higher alert, pay attention and stay safe), increased risk for those with existing mental fragility, right down to exacerbating OCD symptoms, which might even apply to many more people now. The last two ice cubes in the fridge for my G&T before lunch: I threw them into the sink when I had touched them without washing my hands, but ice is sterile, and even knowing that I had a G&T without ice. Yes, I can see the scoffers already lining up: “snowflake generation!” etc… 🙂 But these things are going to be eating away for a long while, even at those of us who woudn’t say (there but the Grace etc…) we have any specific mental issues.

    Oh, that’s done it. Pause, wait for the first phone call from the fifty people who read that and are going to phone up saying, “Gareth, what do you mean you haven’t any specific mental issues, you MAD TWIT!”

    Like

  4. I think I will, now you did it Frank. I did think about it but I was busy. I think it would be good because it would help me be more aware of the issues in this particular period.

    Which reminds me: can I mention again please, if anybody has counselling skills (I mean proper training in this appeal.) Could you message me or phone Don Vicente, parish priest? His number is on the main page of the PASTORAL section.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.